Released in March 2009 and directed by Peter Cornwell, The Haunting in Connecticut arrived at the height of Hollywood’s late-2000s resurgence of “based on true events” supernatural cinema. Produced by Gold Circle Films and distributed by Lionsgate, the film blends family tragedy, medical trauma, and classic haunted house tropes into a commercially successful horror entry.
Premise and Plot Synopsis
The story centers on the Campbell family, led by mother Sara (Virginia Madsen) and father Peter (Martin Donovan). Desperate to ease the grueling commute for their teenage son Matt (Kyle Gallner), who is undergoing experimental cancer treatments, Sara rents a spacious Victorian home in upstate Connecticut close to the clinic.
Due to the house’s low rent, the family overlooks its history until Matt begins experiencing grotesque visions. He discovers the basement was once a 1920s mortuary operated by Ramsey Aickman, who conducted occult seances using a young, clairvoyant medium named Jonah. As Matt’s visions escalate, he bonds with a fellow cancer patient and reverend, Nicholas Popescu (Elias Koteas), who explains that Matt’s proximity to death allows him to perceive trapped spirits. The horror peaks when Matt uncovers the mummified remains of desecrated corpses hidden inside the walls, culminating in a climactic blaze meant to cleanse the house of its necromantic curse.
Fact vs. Fiction: The Snedeker Case
The screenplay—penned by Adam Simon and Tim Metcalfe—draws inspiration from the real-life accounts of Allen and Carmen Snedeker, who rented a former funeral home in Southington, Connecticut, in 1986.
- The Real Claims: The Snedekers reported horrific smells, phantom apparitions, and violent physical assaults, eventually bringing in demonologists Ed and Lorraine Warren. The Warrens declared the home infested with demonic forces resulting from necromancy.
- The Ray Garton Book: Novelist Ray Garton was hired to write the 1992 account In a Dark Place: The Story of a True Haunting. Garton later openly stated that the family’s recollections were contradictory, alcohol-fueled, and frequently embellished by the Warrens’ sensationalist approach.
- Cinematic Inventions: The film diverges significantly from both the book and the real events. Characters like the medium Jonah, the carved runes on corpses, eyelid-cutting rituals, and the house burning down were created wholesale for dramatic horror effect.
Core Themes and Cast Performance
Unlike standard slasher films of its era, The Haunting in Connecticut roots its horror in genuine domestic anguish:
- Medical Dread vs. Paranormal Terror: The narrative’s most effective tension lies in the ambiguity of Matt’s early hallucinations—family members and doctors initially dismiss his visions as side effects of chemotherapy and psychosis.
- Strong Ensemble Anchor: Virginia Madsen delivers emotional weight as a mother unraveling under the fear of losing her son, while Kyle Gallner provides a vulnerable, gaunt, and intensely physical performance that grounds the supernatural elements.
Production, Box Office, and Legacy
Produced on an estimated budget of $18 million, the film grossed $77.5 million worldwide, making it a clear box-office hit despite mixed reviews from critics who cited overreliance on CGI ectoplasm and conventional jump scares.
Its commercial viability led Lionsgate to turn the concept into an anthology franchise, releasing The Haunting in Connecticut 2: Ghosts of Georgia in 2013, though the sequel shared no narrative connection to the original film.
To read the rest of my Monstrous Movie Reviews, click HERE! To add this movie to your film collection, click on the Blu-ray cover below.
