Directed by Tyler MacIntyre, Tragedy Girls (2017) is a razor-sharp, candy-coated horror-comedy that blends the satirical venom of Heathers with the meta-slasher mechanics of Scream. At a time when modern horror frequently leans into somber allegory, Tragedy Girls stands out by delivering unapologetic, high-energy entertainment powered by pitch-black wit and blood-soaked practical effects.
The Clout-Chasing Duo
The film centers on high school seniors Sadie Cunningham (Brianna Hildebrand) and McKayla Hooper (Alexandra Shipp), two true-crime-obsessed best friends running a titular social media brand. Tired of waiting for breaking news in their sleepy Midwestern town of Rosedale, the pair decide to manufacture their own headlines.
After capturing the local serial killer, Lowell (Kevin Durand), and chaining him up in a garage to learn the trade, Sadie and McKayla take the killing spree into their own hands—documenting every gruesome mystery online to skyrocket their follower count.
What Makes It Work
- Magnetic Lead Chemistry: The foundation of the film is the electric dynamic between Shipp and Hildebrand. They portray sociopathy with infectious charm and genuine teenage warmth, treating gruesome murders with the casual enthusiasm of planning a school pep rally.
- Smart Social Media Satire: Rather than presenting a tired “phones are bad” moral lecture, the script treats social media as a natural extension of teenage narcissism, peer validation, and modern true-crime obsession.
- Creative and Gory Kills: MacIntyre does not pull punches on practical gore. From gym equipment catastrophes to inventive dismemberment, the kills are imaginative, visceral, and laced with slapstick timing.
- Strong Ensemble Cast: Memorable supporting turns from Craig Robinson as a self-serious local firefighter, Josh Hutcherson as an ex-boyfriend, and Kevin Durand as a bewildered, veteran serial killer give the world texture and constant comedic momentum.
A Cult Slasher Standout
Tragedy Girls succeeds because it commits entirely to its subversive premise without blinking. Sadie and McKayla are not misunderstood antiheroes seeking redemption; they are driven, ambitious villains whose unbreakable female friendship serves as the emotional core of the film. Stylishly shot, vividly colored, and briskly paced, it remains one of the freshest, most entertaining teen horror comedies of the 2010s.
To read the rest of my Monstrous Movie Reviews, click HERE! To add this movie to your film collection, click on the Blu-ray cover below.
